AmortMapWhat a given loan amount actually costs per month, and over its life.

Monthly payment on a $5,000 car loan at 11%

$5,000 at 11%
$109per month over 60 months
$95 over 72 months, $129 over 48 — the same debt, 649 dollars apart in interest
Monthly payment by term$12948 mo$1,203 interest$10960 mo$1,523 interest$9572 mo$1,852 interest$8684 mo$2,191 interestThe bars fall, the interest rises — $649 more from 48 to 72 months
48-month payment$1,203 total interest$129
60-month payment$1,523 total interest$109
72-month payment$1,852 total interest$95
84-month payment$2,191 total interest$86
Cost of stretching 48 → 72saves $34 a month and costs that much over the loan$649
Underwater until roughlyon a 72-month loan, against a −20% first year and −15% a year aftermonth 37
Per $1,000 borrowedat 11% over 60 months$21.74

Notes

  • The term does more to the payment than the rate does. Moving this loan from 48 to 72 months drops the monthly figure by $34, which no realistic rate negotiation would achieve. It also adds $649 in interest. A dealer who asks "what payment are you looking for" is asking which term to sell you, not which price.
  • Negative equity is the real cost of a long term. A car loses roughly a fifth of its value in the first year. On 72 months this loan is worth less than it owes until about month 37 — and trading in during that window rolls the shortfall into the next loan, where it earns interest again.
  • The advertised rate belongs to a credit tier, not to the car. Spreads between the best and worst tiers run 10 percentage points or more on used vehicles, which on this amount is the difference between $97 and $122 a month.
  • Sales tax, title and fees are financed too, unless you pay them separately. They add roughly 6–10% to the amount borrowed in most states, so the payment above understates the real bill by about that much whenever the figure quoted is the sticker price rather than the amount financed.

The short answer

A $5,000 car loan at 11% is $109 a month over 60 months.

Stretch it to 72 and the payment falls to $95. Shorten it to 48 and it rises to $129. Same car, same rate — $649 apart in total interest.

Every term, side by side

Term Payment Total interest
48 months $129 $1,203
60 months $109 $1,523
72 months $95 $1,852
84 months $86 $2,191

The term moves the payment more than the rate does

Going from 48 to 72 months drops the monthly figure by $34. No rate negotiation available to an ordinary buyer does that — a full percentage point off the rate is worth a fraction of it.

That is why the question "what monthly payment are you looking for?" is asked before the price is settled. Answering it tells the desk which term to write, and the term is where the money is.

Being underwater is the real cost of a long term

A new car loses roughly a fifth of its value in the first year and about 15% of the remainder each year after. Debt on a 72-month loan comes down slower than that for a long time.

On this loan the balance stays above the car's value until month 37. Trading in before then means rolling the shortfall into the next loan, where it earns interest a second time.

Gap insurance covers the same shortfall for a total loss, not for a voluntary trade — those are different problems with similar arithmetic.

What the sticker price leaves out

Sales tax, title, registration and dealer fees are usually financed along with the car. In most states they add 6–10% to the amount borrowed.

So a $5,000 car is rarely a $5,000 loan. The figure to put in a calculator is the amount financed on the contract, not the price on the window.

The rate belongs to a credit tier

Advertised rates are for the top tier. The spread to the bottom tier runs ten points or more on used vehicles — which on this amount is the difference between roughly $109 and a payment half again as large.

Checking a rate with a credit union before walking in converts that from an unknown into a number you already hold.

Nearby sizes

Read more